Skip to content

Potentially huge windfall for creditors of Essar Steel Algoma

Global accounting firm Ernst & Young believes creditors of supposedly insolvent Essar Steel Algoma Inc. may own five per cent of net profits from a $1.5 billion gold mine
160514ErnstandYoungMP1116
Ernst and Young's Toronto office at 222 Bay Street is pictured in this file photo. Michael Purvis/Village Media

Their full value has yet to be determined, but Santa may have just dropped some massive gold nuggets in the stockings of those who lost out in the 2015 insolvency of Essar Steel Algoma Inc.

SooToday has learned that a mining asset formerly owned by Algoma Steel, previously thought essentially worthless, may give Essar creditors a significant stake in a still-under-construction mine expected to produce 5.5 million ounces of gold, with potential for more.

In a Toronto courtroom on Wednesday, Superior Court Justice Peter J. Osborne ordered that Essar Algoma remain under insolvency protection until June 30, 2023.

Essar's protection from its creditors was to expire at year's end.

The extension will allow accounting firm Ernst & Young, acting as court-appointed monitor, time to sort out whether Essar Algoma creditors are entitled to a piece of the Geraldton, Ont. gold mine's action.

Essar Algoma's name was ingloriously changed to Old Steelco Inc. after most of its assets were sold to new owners in November, 2018.

The new owners are carrying on business under the 120-year-old steelmaker's original name, Algoma Steel.

A handful of old Algoma Steel mining properties, many acquired by the steelmaker during the 1900s, were among the last Old Steelco properties to be sold off as the monitor worked to close the insolvency file.

In a report prepared last week, Brian Denega and Allen Yao, both vice-presidents at Ernst & Young's Toronto office, said they had "obtained information indicating that Old Steelco is the holder of a five per cent net profit interest royalty and a two per cent net smelter royalty under mining royalty agreements entered into by a predecessor of Old Steelco in respect of mineral claims near Geraldton, Ont. operated by Greenstone Gold Mines."

"Based on information made available to the monitor to date, it appears that there may be material value to the Greenstone Royalties," Denega and Yao wrote.

"The monitor has taken steps to gather additional information needed to assess the value of the Greenstone royalties, including contacting the owner of the Greenstone Gold Mines."

"The monitor will consult with stakeholders and consider options to realize upon the value of those royalties once sufficient information has been received."

"The monitor will report to this court and seek directions with respect to activities regarding the Greenstone Royalties, if needed."

As SooToday's sister publication Northern Ontario Business reported this week, construction of the Greenstone Gold Mine is at the 50 per cent mark.

The first gold pour there is planned for the first half of 2024.

The massive project is creating 1,800 construction jobs and more than 500 mining-related jobs.

Over the mine's estimated 15-year lifetime, more than 5.5 million ounces of gold will be produced there.

Based on current gold prices, 5.5 million ounces could be worth $3.5 billion.

The insolvency of Essar Steel Algoma saddled 125 Sault creditors with more than $38 million in debt.

The following list of local unsecured creditors of Essar Steel Algoma Inc. was compiled by SooToday from unaudited court records in November 2015:

TRIPLE M METAL LP
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$4,051,098

ALGOMA TUBES INC.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,566,395

SUPERIOR INDUSTRIAL SERVICES
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,477,928

R.F. CONTRACTING
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,400,747

INTER ONTARIO EQUIPMENT RENTAL
SAULT STE. MARIE
$1,197,130

S&T INDUSTRIAL INC.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$761,016

NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$698,459

PURVIS MARINE LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$650,004

BICKELL SCRAPPIES MOBILE AUTO CRUS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$636,901

PUC SERVICES INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$629,908

SLING-CHOKER MFG (SAULT) LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$579,189

ALGOMA INDUSTRIAL LTD.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$485,663

BDI CANADA INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$471,645

WESTBURNE RUDDY ELECTRIC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$463,779

BETA FLUID POWER
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$370,407

POWER FUELS AND LUBRICANTS INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$365,025

MCLEOD BROS MECHANICAL
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$362,045

AIR LIQUIDE CANADA INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$359,060

ENVIROTEK SEALING AND FIBERGLASSING
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$349,434

NATIONAL SUPPLY CENTRE LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$340,985

PORPEALIA REPAIRS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$325,968

FOUNTAIN TIRE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$318,289

SYSTEM INT'L MACHINE SHOP LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$313,495

WAJAX INDUSTRIAL COMPONENTS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$303,261

GHD LIMITED
SAULT STE MARIE ON
$301,140

TOROMONT
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$299,133

BELTERRA CORPORATION
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$299,012

HYDRAULIC SOLUTIONS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$295,980

NEDCO
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$254,740

SAULT COLLEGE OF APPLIED ARTS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$254,454

GROUP HEALTH CENTRE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$234,859

1848707 ONTARIO LTD.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$213,697

WEBER SUPPLY CO INC.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$212,682

RAINONE CONSTRUCTION (2007) LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$212,468

SOO FOUNDRY & MACHINE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$207,870

MANITOULIN TRANSPORT
SAULT STE MARIE ON
$183,376

H WELLWOOD & SONS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$181,653

CHINA STEEL INC.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$173,077

WOLSELEY CANADA INC
SAULT STE. MARIE
$168,012

GUILLEVIN INTERNATIONAL INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$160,445

CONSTRUCTION EQUIP (SAULT) INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$151,332

RECTOR MACHINE WORKS LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$150,346

STERLING CRANE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$143,078

1372055 ONTARIO LIMITED
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$142,649

FINAL TOUCH PROPERTY
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$138,995

SOO ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$129,752

LAKEWAY TRUCK CENTRE LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$111,446

SHELL CANADA LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$108,165

SYLVAN AUTOMATION LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$103,319

ARGO INDUSTRIAL SERVICES
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$97,213

SAFE & SOUND
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$90,790

PINCHIN
SAULT STE. MARIE, ON
$87,301

TRADERS STEEL WAREHOUSE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$86,980

MCDOUGALL FUELS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$85,769

CANADIAN BEARINGS LIMITED
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$85,421

CHRISTIE'S CAMPER SALES LTD.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$83,050

MICROAGE COMPUTER CENTRES
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$74,332

STONE'S OFFICE SUPPLY INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$55,615

EQUIPMENT WORLD INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$50,708

ALGOMA UNIVERSITY
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$50,000

NFP NORTHERN FLUID POWER
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$47,540

THAYER LUMBER CO LIMITED
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$46,224

MICROAGE TECHNICAL SERVICES
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$44,096

SPECTRUM TELECOM GROUP LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$43,091

WASTE MANAGEMENT OF CANADA
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$38,721

GREYWALL COATINGS INC.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$33,779

PARTSOURCE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$30,895

SHAW MILLING LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$29,622

SERVICE RENTALS & SALES
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$26,697

ELLIOTT ENGINEERING
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$24,386

ALGO ELECTRIC LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$23,311

S&T ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$21,014

DULUX PAINT
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$17,775

FISHER WAVY INC
SAULT STE. MARIE, ON
$17,104

RAINONE SERVICES
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$16,745

SUPERIOR PROPANE INC.
ECHO BAY ON
$16,048

SUPERIOR SLAG PRODUCTS INC.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$15,479

STEM ENGINEERING GROUP INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$15,396

TMS TRUCK CENTRE LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$15,376

MAIN FILTER INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$15,222

STEEL SPEED INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$14,620

OCP CONSTRUCTION SUPPLIES INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$14,432

PURE H2O
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$13,023

CLIFFS NATURAL RESOURCES
CLEVELAND OH
$12,377

CLIFFE PRINTING (1979) LIMITED
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$12,535

H R LASH LIMITED
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$11,941

BATTLEFIELD EQUIPMENT RENTALS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$10,376

PRO NORTH ROOFING & GENERAL
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$9,600

ALGOMA CONSTRUCTION SERVICES
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$8,965

RUSCIO MASONRY AND CONSTRUCTION LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$8,586

PROPERTY MASTERS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$8,425

BRANDES AGGREGATES LIMITED
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$7,614

BONIFERRO MILL WORKS ULC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$7,500

BDO CANADA LLP
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$6,780

MAITLAND LEWIS MOTORS LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$5,939

BERGAMIN'S FOOTWEAR & REPAIR
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$5,259

DUMANSKI OFFICE INTERIORS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$4,975

GLASS EMPLOYEE'S LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$4,076

SOO RAINBOW SPRINKLERS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$4,054

LYONS BUILDING CENTRE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$3.972

ALGOMA AUTO-ELECTRIC REBUILDERS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$3,968

DIXON ELECTRIC (SSM) LTD.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$3,808

SOO MILL AND LUMBER CO LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$3,628

PINE ISLAND WOOD PRODUCTS
DESBARATS ON
$3,600

RA ENGINEERS & INSPECTORS INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$2,908

THE SAULT STAR
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$2,860

NUTRI-LAWN
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$2,695

HOWARD AVERY CONSTRUCTION LTD
SAULT STE MARIE ON
$2,683

MOBILE GLASS & FRAMING GALLERY
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$2,647

MDIS INTELLIGENCE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$2,224

APR WELDING CONSULTANTS
SAULT STE. MARIE ONa
$2,147

GREAT LAKES BUS TOURS
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$2,034

SPADONI'S FURNITURE & APPLIANCE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,961

G&K SERVICES CANADA INC.
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,838

MANZZUTTI MARINE SERVICES
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,836

HOLLOWMETAL ARCHITECTURAL HARDWARE LTD
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,681

GARDEWINE GROUP INC.
SAULT STE MARIE ON
$1,577

TML SUPPLY INC
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,564

SOO VAN & STORAGE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,516

ALL NORTH TRUCK CENTRE
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,500

TRIO SUPPLY
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,240

A K GRAPHIX
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,120

ALGOMA OFFICE EQUIPMENT
SAULT STE. MARIE ON
$1,015

— SooToday, with files from Ian Ross, Northern Ontario Business